The church’s Board of Trustees announced the decision in a statement on Tuesday, November 17, following a review of the church’s constitution and recorded instructions left by the founder before his death in 2023.
“The Board of Trustees of The Fountain of Life Church (the “Church”) wishes to inform members of the Church, and the general public, of the outcome of its deliberations on the Church’s leadership and succession arrangements,” the statement reads.
“Following a careful consideration of the relevant provisions of the Church’s Constitution and a review of the recorded instructions of our beloved Founder, the Board of Trustees (the “Board”) has resolved to give effect to the succession arrangements which he made prior to his demise in 2023.
“Consequently, Pastor Jimmy Odukoya is no longer recognized as the Senior Pastor of The Fountain of Life Church effective immediately.”
The board explained that the decision was taken to uphold the church’s constitution, honour the founder’s wishes and protect the leadership succession arrangements he had established.
Taiwo and his wife, Bimbo, founded the church in 1992. Following his death in August 2023, the board said it took steps to ensure continuity in the church’s leadership and appointed Jimmy as senior pastor in what it described as a decision made in good faith.
However, the board said it recently discovered a video recording made in December 2021, in which the late founder outlined his wishes regarding who should succeed him and the responsibilities of other members of the pastoral team.
According to the statement, Jimmy recorded the video at his father’s request, but it was not presented to the board when it initially sought clarification on whether the founder had left succession instructions.
“The recording was made by Pastor Jimmy Odukoya at the Founder’s request, as the Founder’s last wish and directions, and it was witnessed,” it stated.
“Unfortunately, it was not presented to the Board when enquiry was made as to whether the late Pastor Taiwo Odukoya had left succession instructions.
“This led to the wrongful appointment of Pastor Jimmy Odukoya as Senior Pastor, based on the version of events he presented to the Board at the time.”
The board said the recording showed that Taiwo had already identified his preferred successor and assigned specific responsibilities to other members of the church’s pastoral team.
It added that the late founder had designated Jimmy to serve as his successor’s assistant on administrative matters and head of the youth church.
The instructions, according to the board, were intended to take effect upon Taiwo’s death or if he became unable to communicate, particularly if the proposed review of the church’s constitution had not been completed.
After reviewing the recording and the relevant constitutional provisions, the board said it concluded that the founder had exercised his succession authority before his death.
“Its review has confirmed that the late Founder had exercised his succession authority and communicated his intentions before his passing,” it stated.
The board also expressed concern over recent developments involving Jimmy, an actor who has continued his acting career while serving in church leadership and recently introduced his new wife to the congregation.
“The Board is also deeply concerned about recent developments, including Pastor Jimmy Odukoya’s remarriage and its public blessing,” the statement added.
“The Board considers these matters contrary to the teachings of the Church, the values of the Founders, and to the standards expected of its spiritual leadership. They have caused distress among members and brought the Church into public controversy and disrepute.”